So I took an adderall to do some homework and finished in 15 min, so now I'm feeling like doing something time consuming, if you think this is a waste of time you are probably right. Anyway, these are the players I would want on my team to win a Superbowl THIS YEAR.

Quarteback:
1. P. Manning
2. D. McNabb
3. T. Brady
4. C. Palmer
5. M. Bulger
6. D. Carr
7. R. Grossman
8. D. Brees
9. P. Rivers
10. M. Hasselbeck

Honorable Mention: M. Vick (needs to pass better), J. Delhomme (retarded), D. Bledsoe (immobile), E. Manning

Running Back (these are difficult to rank, many are a product of O-Line):
1. L. Tomlinson
2. C. Portis
3. T. Barber
4. S. Alexander
5. W. Dunn
6. L. Johnson
7. D. Davis
8. D. McAlister
9. S. Jackson
10. M. Turner (yes I do think this backup is a top 10 RB)

Honorable Mention: D. Foster (can he stay healthy?), T. Bell, Brian Westbrook(tough yards?), F. Gore (fumblitis), E. James (good without Manning?)

Wide Receiver:
1. S. Smith
2. T. Holt
3. C. Johnson
4. T. Owens
5. M. Harrison
6. L. Fitzgerald
7. S. Moss
8. A. Boldin
9. L. Coles
10. R. Wayne

Honorable Mention: K. Johnson, B. Edwards, R. Williams, D. Stallworth, S Jackson

Tight End:
1. A. Gates
2. A. Crumpler
3. J. Shockey
4. T. Gonzales
5. T. Heap

Honorable Mention: J. Witten, H. Miller

Fullback:
1. L. Neal
2. M. Alstott
3. M. Strong
4. F. Beasly
5. C. Cooley

(I admit I don't know much about FB's)

Kickers (also hard to judge, depends on where the offense puts you):
1. A. Vinitieri
2. N. Rackers
3. J. Kasay
4. D. Akers
5. J. Carney

Defensive End:
1. J. Peppers
2. M. Strahan
3. J. Abraham
4. D. Freeney
5. J. Kearse

Linebacker:
1. R. Lewis
2. B. Urlacher
3. J. Porter
4. S. Merriman
5. Z. Thomas

Honorable Mention: Dan Morgan, the only person on my list negatively affected by injury. He would be in the top 5 if he could stay healthy.

Safety:
1. E. Reed
2. T. Polamalu
3. A. Wilson
4. B. Dawkins
5. J. Lynch

Corners:
1. C. Bailey
2. D. Hall
3. R. Barber
4. K. Lucas
5. C. McAlister

I don't know enough about D tackles, Punters, or O-linemen to rank them.

Well, that was a fun 45 minutes, I love adderall.

[Edited on October 10, 2006 at 3:48 PM. Reason : left out #3 reciever]

10/10/2006 3:20:48 PM

you left out Keyshawn

10/10/2006 3:23:20 PM

He's one of my honorable mentions

10/10/2006 3:24:33 PM

Quote :

"Anyway, these are the players I would want on my team to win a Superbowl THIS YEAR. "

It is funny you put that and then put TOM BRADY as #3 QB.

10/10/2006 3:25:36 PM

Here's to adderall; I just read them all and thought about it really hard.

10/10/2006 3:25:50 PM

i dont see how you can put calvin johnson so high when he's still only in college.

10/10/2006 3:26:41 PM

Quote :

"i dont see how you can put calvin johnson so high when he's still only in college."

ahahaha.

but seriously, if he was in the pros I think he would be in the top ten RIGHT NOW, thats how good he is.

10/10/2006 3:28:10 PM

Chad Johnson you dumbass Asian.

10/10/2006 3:28:26 PM

Gonzalez is so overrated its not even funny

and hcnguyen is still an idiot, whaddya know



[Edited on October 10, 2006 at 3:30 PM. Reason : gfd]

10/10/2006 3:29:36 PM

Quote :

"It is funny you put that and then put TOM BRADY as #3 QB."

Well, I'm not really going on performance to week 5, but more of how good I think they are right now. Brady hasn't been great so far this year, but I still think he is a great QB.

10/10/2006 3:32:14 PM

Quarteback:
1. T. Brady
2. P. Manning
3. D. McNabb
4. C. Palmer
5. M. Bulger

Running Back
1. L. Tomlinson
2. S. Jackson
3. T. Barber
4. S. Alexander
5. C. Portis

Wide Receiver:
1. S. Smith
2. T. Holt
3. C. Johnson
4. T. Owens
5. M. Harrison

Tight End:
1. A. Gates
2. K. Winslow
3. J. Shockey (if he could ever play a full season)
4. T. Gonzalez
5. A. Crumpler

Fullback:
1. L. Neal
2. M. Strong

Kickers
1. A. Vinitieri
2. M. Stover
3. J. Kasay
4. J. Elam
5. J. Hanson

Defensive End:
1. J. Peppers
2. R. Mathis
3. D. Freeney
4. J. Taylor
5. J. Kearse

Linebacker:
1. R. Lewis
2. B. Urlacher
3. J. Porter
4. K. Bulluck
5. Z. Thomas

Safety:
1. T. Polamalu
2. E. Reed
3. B. Dawkins
4. A. Wilson
5. M. Lewis

Corners:
1. C. McAlister
2. C. Bailey
3. R. Barber
4. D. Hall

Defensive Tackles:
1. R. Seymour
2. S. Rogers
3. J. Williams
4. J. Henderson
5. M. Stroud

Offensive Tackles:

1. W. Jones
2. W. Anderson
3. J. Ogden

Guards:

1. S. Hutchinson
2. W. Shields
3. D. Woody

Centers:

1. J. Saturday
2. O. Kreutz


Punters:

1. S. Lechler
2. B. Moorman

[Edited on October 10, 2006 at 3:43 PM. Reason : .]

10/10/2006 3:42:51 PM

Not a bad list, but a few definetly don't seem right.

Brady should be over McNabb. Grossman at least over Carr. Urlacher & Merriman are better than Ray Lewis (he's just too old to still be that high). Ken Lucas the 4th CB? He's not even the best CB on the Panthers & has been terrible this year.

10/10/2006 3:43:42 PM

Quote :

"Brady should be over McNabb. Grossman at least over Carr. Urlacher & Merriman are better than Ray Lewis (he's just too old to still be that high). Ken Lucas the 4th CB? He's not even the best CB on the Panthers & has been terrible this year."

McNabb has always been better than Brady, except last year when he was hurt. Brady has had a better team and perhaps you could say he is more "clutch," but I would still rather have McNabb on my team.

You MAY have a point with Urlacher (I don't agree), but I would still rather have Ray easily than Merriman, Merriman plays with skill and passion, but Lewis plays with skill, passions, AND intellegence. Ray would never have allowed Heap to score that last touchdown in the Ravens/Chargers game.

Lucas you might be right, I'm a bit of a Panthers homer, but I think he is more dependable of a corner than Gamble.

BTW, I screwed up the WR's.
It should read:

Quote :

" Wide Receiver: 1. S. Smith 2. T. Holt 3. R. Moss 4. C. Johnson 5. T. Owens 6. M. Harrison 7. L. Fitzgerald 8. S. Moss 9. A. Boldin 10. L. Coles Honorable Mention: R. Wayne, K. Johnson, B. Edwards, R. Williams, D. Stallworth, S Jackson"

10/10/2006 3:56:16 PM

Saurbraun #1 punter (however the hell you spell it, he's so drunk he won't notice)

10/10/2006 4:02:20 PM

^hes so good that he got cut by the broncos today

10/10/2006 4:18:08 PM

you people are all insane

10/10/2006 4:22:28 PM

why that chickenheaded Randy Moss is on anyone's list is beyond me

10/10/2006 4:23:05 PM

delhomme=top 10 qb

10/10/2006 4:25:11 PM

the sourbun? they were talking about how the other punter was fighting for his job last night.

Quote :

"J. Delhomme (retarded), "

nice

here's my list

quarterbacks

1. brady
2. brees
3. rivers
4. palmer
5. hussleback
6. mcnabb
7. P. manning (i really dont like this guy though)
8. palmer
9. pennington
10. grossman

honorable mention: lionheart

10/10/2006 4:26:56 PM

that is horrible

10/10/2006 4:28:17 PM

1. Bears Defense

10/10/2006 4:29:02 PM

that's the worst list I have ever seen.

Palmer is both your #4 and #8 QB?

10/10/2006 4:29:09 PM

dylan
dylan
dylan
dylan
dylan

10/10/2006 4:29:43 PM

these are the guys that get it done, payton is another alex rodrigues, he'll get you to the playoffs then choke

10/10/2006 4:30:06 PM

^ive never heard of either of those players...are you sure you arent referring to alex rodriguez, and peyton manning

10/10/2006 4:31:43 PM

^^yeah cause brees, rivers, palmer, hasselbeck, mcnabb, pennington, grossman, and leinhart have all had so much success winning superbowls

[Edited on October 10, 2006 at 4:31 PM. Reason : ^^]

10/10/2006 4:31:48 PM

I must have missed when Brees, Pennington, or Palmer "got it done" in the playoffs.

10/10/2006 4:31:53 PM

This list is a little misconstrued, D.Davis as a runningback along with Michael Turner---There are far better running backs out there so try Rudi Johnson, Willie Parker. I believe both of them have far better numbers than 4 of your top 5, and both are team players.

10/10/2006 4:36:42 PM

^^ all three never got a fair chance, peyton has had enough chances.
but if i had money to build a team thats who i'd go with

10/10/2006 4:39:38 PM

Actually I was wanting to put Rudi Johnson in the top 10, but when I didn't find room I figured I would put him in Honorable Mention, then forgot about it.

10/10/2006 4:40:36 PM

^^why wouldnt you put McNabb over Brees for example?

[Edited on October 10, 2006 at 4:41 PM. Reason : ^^]

10/10/2006 4:41:02 PM

Quote :

"^^ all three never got a fair chance, peyton has had enough chances. but if i had money to build a team thats who i'd go with"

They haven't had as many chances because they can't carry a team to the playoffs like Manning can.

Choking in the playoffs is a ligitimate argument, but you can't say they are worse than players who aren't good enough in the regular season to MAKE the playoffs.

10/10/2006 4:42:49 PM

it goes down to the old Marino argument

I'd still want Peyton as my #1 guy this year though I wouldnt have a problem with anybody saying Brady (he's won a few), McNabb (he's won a lot of games), Rivers (I love State)

10/10/2006 4:43:55 PM

just on momentum, brees has had two going on three solid years, mcnabb is having a good year but its early

but please dont take my list toooooo seriously, the list could change dramatically, exept for brady

10/10/2006 4:44:21 PM

Quote :

"just on momentum, brees has had two going on three solid years, mcnabb is having a good year but its early"

Before last year McNabb had FOUR great years, then he was injured.

10/10/2006 4:45:27 PM

brees' injury didnt come into consideration?

i mean everybodys got their opinions of course...but if you share them on the internet you're bound to have people disagree and explain why hopefully

ps Delhomme for President

10/10/2006 4:45:28 PM

delhomme, i can never fully trust that guy, he always has this "im about to seriously fuck up" look about him

10/10/2006 4:47:10 PM

If you dont have Peyton as your #1 QB then you are a fucking fool and know jack about football

10/10/2006 4:47:37 PM

^^I would take Peyton and a few others over Delhomme

however, he HAS led his team to 2 conference title games and 1 superbowl in the span of 3 years

so fuck brees' accomplishments if you look at those stats

^easy now...I pretty much agree, but don't let your volunteer homerism overlook Brady

10/10/2006 4:48:56 PM

i'd definately have him as my #1 signal caller

10/10/2006 4:49:08 PM

Quarteback:
1. P. Rivers
2. P. Rivers
3. P. Rivers
4. P. Rivers
5. P. Rivers
6. P. Rivers
7. P. Rivers
8. P. Rivers
9. P. Rivers
10. P. Rivers

Running Back (these are difficult to rank, many are a product of O-Line):
1. P. Rivers
2. P. Rivers
3. P. Rivers
4. P. Rivers
5. P. Rivers
6. P. Rivers
7. P. Rivers
8. P. Rivers
9. P. Rivers
10. P. Rivers

Wide Receiver:
1. T. Holt
2. J. Cotchery
3. P. Rivers
4. P. Rivers
5. P. Rivers
6. P. Rivers
7. P. Rivers
8. P. Rivers
9. P. Rivers
10. P. Rivers

Tight End:
1. P. Rivers
2. P. Rivers
3. P. Rivers
4. P. Rivers
5. P. Rivers


Phil can do it all!

10/10/2006 4:52:49 PM

Ev:

no love for K-Rob?

10/10/2006 4:53:23 PM

not being a homer at all, totally objective. Once again, Peyton has had a good defense for 1.3 years, Brady has had one every year until last year (when they werent that great) and this year (when they are so so). You give Manning the defense that Brady had for 4 previous years, and I have no doubt he would have won at least one super bowl.

[Edited on October 10, 2006 at 4:53 PM. Reason : d]

10/10/2006 4:53:27 PM

i would take manning over brady

but brady has the intangibles of no other QB we've seen in the NFL over the last 5-10 years

10/10/2006 4:54:27 PM

Quarterback:
1. D. McNabb
2. P. Manning
3. C. Palmer
4. T. Brady
5. P. Rivers - seriously. mofo is dank as hell. "free philip rivers"!

Running Back:
1. L. Tomlinson
2. B. Westbrook
3. W. Dunn
4. C. Portis
5. E. James

Wide Receiver:
1. T. Owens
2. T. Holt
3. C. Johnson
4. S. Smith
5. R. Moss

Tight End:
1. A. Gates
2. J. Shockey
3. T. Heap
4. A. Crumpler
5. T. Gonzales

Fullback:
1. L. Neal - the stat the nfl keeps showing about him blocking for 1,000+ rushers everywhere he goes
2. really though, who gives a fuck about fullbacks?

Kicker:
1. again, who gives a fuck?

Defensive End:
1. J. Peppers
2. D. Freeney
3. A. Kampman
4. M. Strahan
5. J. Smith

Linebacker:
1. B. Urlacher
2. R. Lewis
3. J. Porter
4. L. Tatupu
5. S. Merriman

Safety:
1. E. Reed
2. B. Dawkins
3. J. Lynch
4. R. Harrison
5. T. Polamalu

Corners:
1. D. Hall
2. C. Bailey
3. C. McAlister
4. R. Barber
5. S. Spencer

Defensive Tackles:
1. J. Williams
2. K. Williams
3. T. Harris
4. R. Seymour
5. M. Stroud

[Edited on October 10, 2006 at 5:40 PM. Reason : ]

10/10/2006 5:37:01 PM

im pretty sure tatupu's first name is lofa

10/10/2006 5:39:21 PM

you're right. i think the "t" in tatupu dominated my thinking

10/10/2006 5:41:23 PM

Punters
1. J. Feagles

10/10/2006 5:42:27 PM

Punters:
1. J. Deraney

just wait. he doesn't have the strongest punting leg, but he is on the money.

[Edited on October 10, 2006 at 5:44 PM. Reason : ]

10/10/2006 5:43:05 PM

Deraney won't be a punter, at least I hope.

Nobody cares about punters, and if your punter comes out you are already dissapointed anyway.

10/10/2006 6:21:35 PM