shoot All American 7611 Posts user info edit post |
Clemson vs UNC starts at 8 pm this Saturday, which means ending around midnight. 11/29/2015 2:38:46 PM |
ncstatetke All American 41128 Posts user info edit post |
what a slap in the face. Jerry Palm of CBS Sports has Northwestern projected to play Tennessee in the Outback Bowl
#13 team in the world versus the 6th best team in the SEC (and receiving 8 votes in the current poll) 11/29/2015 8:31:14 PM |
Jaybee1200 Suspended 56200 Posts user info edit post |
sounds about right to me.
also
https://www.dawgnation.com/football/team-news/leonard-floyd-to-reporters-im-gone
[Edited on November 29, 2015 at 9:20 PM. Reason : d] 11/29/2015 9:05:41 PM |
prb185 All American 1589 Posts user info edit post |
Someone assure me UNC won't beat Clemson 11/29/2015 10:25:09 PM |
Big4Country All American 11914 Posts user info edit post |
^I'm scared too. Clemson has given up 22+ points in 5 games this season. They haven't really destroyed anyone outside of Miami. UNC can score a lot too. 11/29/2015 10:36:52 PM |
ncstatetke All American 41128 Posts user info edit post |
Clemson is no offensive slouch either. They've scored over 33 points in 9 games
they can give up 35 to UNC for all I care, just as long as they score the 37 they're averaging this season 11/29/2015 10:40:44 PM |
Big4Country All American 11914 Posts user info edit post |
^I hope they put up 37+ on them. I don't want UNC to get to the playoff. 11/29/2015 10:45:35 PM |
shoot All American 7611 Posts user info edit post |
Gonna be very competitive, I can smell. 11/30/2015 8:42:46 AM |
themayor All American 1473 Posts user info edit post |
After watching both games, Im not sure that UNC isnt the better team. Their O-line looks superior, their receivers are deeper and the run game is superior. Clearly Clempson's D is better but I'm not sure that will offset UNC's O. UNC getting 6 isnt surprising but I'd put my $$$ on UNC as bad as I hate to say it. 11/30/2015 9:02:11 AM |
LudaChris All American 7946 Posts user info edit post |
The funny thing is, even if UNC beats Clemson, they need a ton of help to make the playoffs.
UNC winning really just trashes the ACC's chances at the playoffs. I expect you'll see a lot of questionable calls in favor of Clemson this week, much like you saw in the UNC/NCSU game last week that went in UNC's favor.
Playoff Spots: Oklahoma - locked. Iowa/Michigan St. winner - locked. Alabama - basically locked, 2+ TD favorite over UF.
4th spot will be Clemson's if they win, Stanford's if Clemson loses and they win, tOSU if both lose. UNC would have to beat Clemson, have Alabama lose despite being 17-point favorites, and have Stanford lose to USC.
[Edited on November 30, 2015 at 9:29 AM. Reason : .] 11/30/2015 9:28:28 AM |
Doss2k All American 18474 Posts user info edit post |
I agree that's how it should play out, but don't put it past the committee to put UNC in just like they did with Ohio State last year. I want to see where 6-10 fall this week. That will give us a slight idea although again we saw last year how that didn't really matter. 11/30/2015 9:45:00 AM |
The E Man Suspended 15268 Posts user info edit post |
I expect UNC will jump Stanford Tomorrow. In that case, they only need to jump past Ohio State to get in with a win. I'd expect that to happen as well. The comittee values conference championships and Ohio State is the odd team in in that case.
Oklahoma - lock Michigan State/Iowa- lock Clemson/UNC Alabama or (Ohio State or Stanford)
[Edited on November 30, 2015 at 9:47 AM. Reason : Why do people think 2 loss stanford would beat out 1 loss UNC?] 11/30/2015 9:46:16 AM |
dmspack oh we back 25535 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | " 4th spot will be Clemson's if they win, Stanford's if Clemson loses and they win, tOSU if both lose." |
i think last year showed that the committee valued winning your conference. i'm of the opinion that unc, with a win over clemson, would jump ohio st. obviously, other things would have to fall into place as well.
[Edited on November 30, 2015 at 10:01 AM. Reason : f]11/30/2015 10:00:16 AM |
shoot All American 7611 Posts user info edit post |
So UNC should just let Clemson win and do Clemson a favor. 11/30/2015 10:08:51 AM |
LudaChris All American 7946 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Why do people think 2 loss stanford would beat out 1 loss UNC?" |
Stanford(10-2) SOS: 16th Good Wins: @ #6 USC, #18 UCLA, #6 ND. Bad Losses: None.
UNC(11-1) SOS: 43rd Good Wins: @ #23 Pitt Bad Losses: USCe
Obviously beating Clemson would help their resume, but based on just what they've done so far, I'll take 2 losses to teams that ended up ranked over a team that lost to a bad South Carolina team and beat 2 FCS teams.11/30/2015 10:27:08 AM |
Big4Country All American 11914 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "i think last year showed that the committee valued winning your conference. i'm of the opinion that unc, with a win over clemson, would jump ohio st. obviously, other things would have to fall into place as well." |
Exactly! They said they will give special considerations to conference champions, look at who wins head to head, and look at records vs common opponents. As much as I hate to say it, UNC will be in if they win the league over #1 Clemson. They will only have one loss and that was early in the season. You have to give them credit for that. Oklahoma also has a bad loss to Texas, so taking Oklahoma and leaving out ACC champion UNC would make no sense at all. Hopefully Clemson wins.
Iowa/Michigan State Oklahoma Clemson/UNC Alabama
Maybe: One loss Clemson, Ohio State, or a 2 loss team.11/30/2015 12:38:57 PM |
ndmetcal All American 9012 Posts user info edit post |
Oklahoma & Bama are in (only way Bama loses to Florida is if their bus falls off a cliff on the way to the game) along with the MSU/Iowa winner
If Clemson wins they're obviously in as the 4th team. If Clemson loses, I would expect Ohio State to be the 4th team. Only way I think UNC gets a chance is if they beat Clemson handily. I think Iowa beating MSU would also help UNC a little 11/30/2015 12:45:08 PM |
LudaChris All American 7946 Posts user info edit post |
As much as the committee values conference titles, they already said they were going to hold playing 2 FCS teams against UNC and that the South Carolina loss would be really bad(look at who USCe lost to this year). I think UNC was more interested in padding the wins column with their schedule than trying to be competitive for the playoffs, and it could end up really costing them.
All speculation at this point, but I think they'd have to beat Clemson by double-digits to really make a profound leap to the top 4 spots since realistically 3 of them are claimed and they're still behind Stanford and tOSU in the current rankings. 11/30/2015 1:03:31 PM |
wstcoastwolf All American 1642 Posts user info edit post |
All preseason the pundits said the ACC was weak and would be the odd conference left out of the playoffs if the champion was not undefeated (referring to either FSU or Clemson). Do you really think a UNC team that still has yet to play a team ranked in the top 25 by the selection committee and has a loss to a 3-9 team will make it? 11/30/2015 1:32:47 PM |
Doss2k All American 18474 Posts user info edit post |
Only because that is the sort of shit that happens to me as a sports fan. Realistically they should be behind 4 or 5 other schools at least. 11/30/2015 2:08:17 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148439 Posts user info edit post |
UNC lost to a team that lost to the Citadel, and their best win of the season through 12 games is versus Pittsburgh? They'd need so much to happen for them to get a shot at making the top 4. Not gonna happen. 11/30/2015 2:35:13 PM |
Doss2k All American 18474 Posts user info edit post |
Hopefully Clemson beats them by 30 and this is all moot. 11/30/2015 2:38:12 PM |
shoot All American 7611 Posts user info edit post |
Could be very tight, till the last min 11/30/2015 3:39:57 PM |
titans78 All American 4038 Posts user info edit post |
UNC won't jump tOSU, especially if MSU wins making a one loss tOSU look even better only losing one game to MSU by 3.
So UNC needs to crush Clemson, and 'Bama needs to lose. That is the only way I see them getting in, which would be something like : OK - In already MSU/Iowa Winner - In tOSU UNC
I think UNC can jump Stanford but not tOSU. A real funny scenario would be the MSU/Iowa game coming down to the very end with Iowa losing in OT but both teams looking really good, and 'Bama losing. Could that setup MSU, Iowa, and tOSU all making it at that point with OK? UNC would almost have to be put in if they won just so it wasn't 3 teams from one conference. But would be very easy to argue that all three of those teams are better than UNC, along with a 2 loss 'Bama, 2 loss Florida, and Stanford. I think a one loss team can easily jump or beat out UNC(or stay ahead), but not a two loss if they beat Clemson and look decent doing it.
Most likely it is going to be Clemson, 'Bama, Iowa/MSU, and OK, would be fine with that group of 4, all conference champions, all played good schedules, and would all be fun to watch. 11/30/2015 4:10:31 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148439 Posts user info edit post |
They'd put a 2-loss SEC champ Florida in over a 2nd Big Ten team, despite how terrible the SEC East is
[Edited on November 30, 2015 at 4:33 PM. Reason : .] 11/30/2015 4:33:06 PM |
titans78 All American 4038 Posts user info edit post |
I think if Florida beat 'Bama in like an ugly 14-10 type game where neither team moved the ball well, and MSU won big over Iowa then it could end up something like Clemson, MSU, OK, tOSU. Most likely not but isn't impossible to see that. 11/30/2015 4:39:38 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148439 Posts user info edit post |
I think the SEC champ definitely gets in. I can certainly see scenarios when a 2nd Big Ten team would get in, but not at the expense of the SEC champs, even if it is a team that scored 2 points against Florida State this weekend and damn near lost to Florida Atlantic.
I think Big Ten champs and SEC champs are locks.
Then Clemson if they beat UNC, and most likely Oklahoma
If Clemson loses, I could see Ohio State or Stanford taking that spot. But I don't see a non-SEC playoff, despite the fact that Bama is the only good team in the conference this year
[Edited on November 30, 2015 at 4:42 PM. Reason : .] 11/30/2015 4:41:09 PM |
titans78 All American 4038 Posts user info edit post |
OK is def in at this point, don't think that is in doubt, along with the MSU/Iowa winner. 11/30/2015 4:51:41 PM |
The E Man Suspended 15268 Posts user info edit post |
guys stop talking about florida. florida isn't making it even if they win 35-0. if they somehow beat alabama, it will mostly just discredit alabama. being demolished by a non conference opponent not only confirmed that the sec is not elite, but it gave the acc some legitimacy.
unc could be the ohio state of last year in terms of resume if they win. they would have the strongest win of all teams in contention and would be in. clemson would probably still be ranked ahead of florida at that point.
notre dame losing really cleared things up. had they won, it would've been a complete train wreck of not knowing who to leave out. Ohio state is the only team who could steal the bid from the sec
[Edited on November 30, 2015 at 4:58 PM. Reason : stanford and florida out] 11/30/2015 4:58:08 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148439 Posts user info edit post |
Ohio State got in last year because of name recognition and they beat more than one good team. UNC has zero football name recognition and if they beat Clemson, that would be their only good win all year. And Florida's loss to FSU is MUCH, MUCH better of a loss than losing to South Carolina. 11/30/2015 5:32:57 PM |
sag1804 All American 914 Posts user info edit post |
I am just happy we can discuss this, remember a few years ago??????????????
hmmmmm 11/30/2015 5:57:53 PM |
The E Man Suspended 15268 Posts user info edit post |
Nothings different. Its worse because it pretends to be better. Old system would be clemson vs iowa clearly and would unravel with an msu win 11/30/2015 6:52:38 PM |
shoot All American 7611 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "UNC has zero football name recognition and if they beat Clemson, that would be their only good win all year" |
So who do you think is gonna win, TT?11/30/2015 7:36:25 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148439 Posts user info edit post |
I think Clemson will win by 1-2 Touchdowns. 11/30/2015 7:38:19 PM |
Jaybee1200 Suspended 56200 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "And Florida's loss to FSU is MUCH, MUCH better of a loss than losing to South Carolina." |
but Florida also lost to LSU... 2 losses is not MUCH, MUCH better than losing one game to South Carolina you tart11/30/2015 7:46:41 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148439 Posts user info edit post |
But the media still views the SEC as MUCH, MUCH better than the ACC. 11/30/2015 7:52:05 PM |
Jaybee1200 Suspended 56200 Posts user info edit post |
lol, if UNC beats the #1 team in the country and only has one loss and Florida with two losses beats Bama, UNC will get in 11/30/2015 7:54:05 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148439 Posts user info edit post |
It would be similar to a 2 loss LSU playing for the title instead of a 1 loss Kansas team in whatever year that was
2 losses in the SEC > 1 loss in the ACC
wins over Alabama, Ole Miss and Georgia > 1 win over Clemson
but it seems your trolling method of the day is to try and aggravate people by hyping up UNC's playoff chances, so carry on
[Edited on November 30, 2015 at 8:00 PM. Reason : .] 11/30/2015 7:59:35 PM |
Jaybee1200 Suspended 56200 Posts user info edit post |
did Kansas beat the #1 team in the country in their conf. championship game that year?
just because you dont like it doesnt mean it's trolling...
Quote : | "No. 14 North Carolina (11-1)
Path to the Playoff: Beat Clemson in the ACC championship, have Alabama lose the SEC championship and Stanford lose the Pac-12 championship. Even then, the committee might take Ohio State as a second Big Ten team rather than the Tar Heels. But that could set a precedent against conference championships that the committee might not want to make." |
but I do agree with your view that SEC >>>>>> ACC
[Edited on November 30, 2015 at 8:06 PM. Reason : d]11/30/2015 8:02:49 PM |
TreeTwista10 minisoldr 148439 Posts user info edit post |
no, you're wrong 11/30/2015 8:05:22 PM |
The E Man Suspended 15268 Posts user info edit post |
The irony of that argument is that UNC's horrible loss was to an SEC team. 11/30/2015 8:05:40 PM |
Jaybee1200 Suspended 56200 Posts user info edit post |
it begins
https://www.seccountry.com/florida/uga-5-star-qb-commit-to-take-official-visit-to-florida#.Vl0Fq26TawE.twitter 11/30/2015 9:35:23 PM |
Førte All American 23525 Posts user info edit post |
12 in a row incoming 11/30/2015 9:39:32 PM |
Big4Country All American 11914 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Nothings different. Its worse because it pretends to be better. Old system would be clemson vs iowa clearly and would unravel with an msu win" |
Actually it is better. No matter how many teams get in the playoff there will always be talk about who got in that shouldn't have and who got the shaft. It happens with NCAA basketball all of the time. The 4 team playoff leaves room for the best team to get in even when they have a worse record. Iowa is good, but I think Alabama with 1 loss is still better than them and maybe even Clemson. There were a lot of times with the 2 team playoff that there was a 2+ way tie in overall record. IIRC, the first year of the BCS Tennessee went undefeated while Washington (11-1) beat Miami (11-1), and Miami beat FSU (11-1). Then Tennessee played FSU for the national title. I'm guessing that within the next 30 years there will probably be an 8 team playoff which would work a little better though (P5 champs, G5 #1, 2 at-large bids).11/30/2015 9:43:55 PM |
Doss2k All American 18474 Posts user info edit post |
Lets not forget we are a 4th and 25 lateral miami style play away from Alabama not even winning its division which would have really thrown a wrench into things. 12/1/2015 8:33:08 AM |
laxman490 All American 2385 Posts user info edit post |
Espn just spent a long time talking about UNC and the playoff and they showed continued highlights of the game last week.
[Edited on December 1, 2015 at 6:22 PM. Reason : E] 12/1/2015 6:21:46 PM |
The E Man Suspended 15268 Posts user info edit post |
Quote : | "Actually it is better. No matter how many teams get in the playoff there will always be talk about who got in that shouldn't have and who got the shaft. It happens with NCAA basketball all of the time. The 4 team playoff leaves room for the best team to get in even when they have a worse record." |
It doesn't. Theres not enough games in the season to narrow down the top 4 teams in a season. there are 6 separate domains of teams who don't necessarily play each other so that is the minimum to insure the best team is included each year. tcu may have been the best team last year but we will never know.
in basketball, the best team in the country can't possibly be outside of the top 60
Quote : | " I think Alabama with 1 loss is still better than them and maybe even Clemson. There were a lot of times with the 2 team playoff that there was a 2+ way tie in overall record." |
the idea that humans decide which loss to excuse and which to penalize is whats not fair. There needs to be a computer system or some type of clear requirements (winning your conference, etc) to really be fair.12/1/2015 7:14:20 PM |
Jaybee1200 Suspended 56200 Posts user info edit post |
I agree that winning your conference should be mandatory.
I mean, maybe an exception for the SEC 12/1/2015 7:32:07 PM |
The E Man Suspended 15268 Posts user info edit post |
nd in front of unc despite losing to the only 2 good teams they played. this new system and committee is obviously just an excuse to get the big name programs in the playoffs every year. they literally completely ignore losses by ohio state and alabama. 12/1/2015 7:39:03 PM |
laxman490 All American 2385 Posts user info edit post |
^^so you think the final 4 should be Florida, Oklahoma, USC, and UNC if that is how it plays out this weekend?
[Edited on December 1, 2015 at 7:39 PM. Reason : U] 12/1/2015 7:39:22 PM |