User not logged in - login - register
Home Calendar Books School Tool Photo Gallery Message Boards Users Statistics Advertise Site Info
go to bottom | |
 Message Boards » » Game of Thrones book and show comparisons thread Page 1 ... 11 12 13 14 [15] 16 17 18, Prev Next  
goalielax
All American
11252 Posts
user info
edit post

another case of them eliminating the stuff like above re: jamie and his development.

it happened in this episode (well, this and past ones) by having tyrion delivered directly to dani. he went through so much character development with penny.

5/25/2015 11:06:55 PM

rjrumfel
All American
23027 Posts
user info
edit post

Sooooo, is Sam even going to be going to Old Town now?

5/26/2015 9:49:24 AM

DROD900
All American
24658 Posts
user info
edit post

the only way I could see that happening would be if Jon decided to send him on his Maester journey now that Aemon is dead

This thread is going to be dead soon

5/26/2015 10:03:41 AM

BEU
All American
12512 Posts
user info
edit post

Sam might go if he sees a generic threat to Gilly and/or himself.

But im not sure how he gets out with direct orders from Lord Commander.

It might be that Sams story in Old town simply doesn't matter and might be used as a way to shoe horn historical information at the reader. So they cut the journey out of the show and figure another way to get the info.

5/26/2015 11:09:43 AM

jbrick83
All American
23447 Posts
user info
edit post

Sam has to get away from the Wall...unless Ghost is just going to chill by his side until Jon comes back.

Oh...and as bad as the Sand Snakes have been...those tits were on point.

[Edited on May 26, 2015 at 11:18 AM. Reason : .]

5/26/2015 11:17:36 AM

goalielax
All American
11252 Posts
user info
edit post

haha agreed on the last point. outside the bendy redhead, she's tops

5/26/2015 1:12:05 PM

skokiaan
All American
26447 Posts
user info
edit post

She's 19. 19 year olds defy gravity

[Edited on May 27, 2015 at 3:15 AM. Reason : .]

5/27/2015 3:14:56 AM

federal
All American
2638 Posts
user info
edit post

"Don't worry, Jon always comes back."

ohh shit, pretty close to confirmation of his resurrection right?

6/1/2015 12:05:47 PM

goalielax
All American
11252 Posts
user info
edit post

kinda like "don't worry, kneel and confess your crime and the king will let you live out your life on the night's watch"

6/1/2015 4:53:07 PM

dubcaps
All American
4765 Posts
user info
edit post

given what just happened at hardholme, i have no idea how they can justify the watch turning on jon. it's not like he was the only brother there. ollie is clearly going to be involved.

6/1/2015 9:47:23 PM

BEU
All American
12512 Posts
user info
edit post

Part of me thought it was possible to get Jon with the walkers vs Dany and her dragons. But given that they are being portrayed as pyre evil, it will never happen.

6/1/2015 10:11:58 PM

Shrike
All American
9594 Posts
user info
edit post

There were a lot of theories about Jon or Stannis eventually becoming the leader of the zombie army, but it looks like that job's taken lol.

6/2/2015 9:20:43 AM

jbrick83
All American
23447 Posts
user info
edit post

How popular were those theories?? Those just sound really "out there".

Regardless...that episode was pretty awesome. A lot of shit has been talked about the show-makers...but that battle scene was pretty epic. My only complaint was that maybe the wights were a little too "walking dead-ish"...but I can't remember how they were described in the books, so I don't know if that argument is even valid.

I love Tyrion and Dany together...but that was way too easy for Tyrion. I know he's smooth, but that was a little ridiculous. Also thought she should have said she was going to "burn the wheel" and not break it...ya know..being the mother of dragons and all.

6/2/2015 9:26:23 AM

BEU
All American
12512 Posts
user info
edit post

Anyone remember how the hardhome scene in the books is described? I seem to remember some mention of 'dead things.' When I read it, I got the impression that it was more than just undead men. There were 'things'

6/2/2015 9:33:03 AM

Shrike
All American
9594 Posts
user info
edit post

^^Variations of theories on Stannis or Jon becoming the "Night's King" (remember, this is before we knew he was evil incarnate) were fairly popular. The Stannis one made the most narrative sense, given what we know about the character from the books. It went something like after a crushing defeat at Winterfell, he and his army limp back to the Wall where he is somehow presented with an opportunity to lead the army of the dead, as his only recourse to becoming King of Westeros.

6/2/2015 9:52:32 AM

jbrick83
All American
23447 Posts
user info
edit post

^^ In the post-episode discussion with the show creators, they made it sound like it didn't go into much detail in the book. Just that, "shit-happened" so to speak. I've slowly come to realize that I've forgotten pretty much everything in the books.

6/2/2015 10:06:48 AM

cyrion
All American
27139 Posts
user info
edit post

Yeah, I have terrible memory of all books I've read. Sadly when I try to read them again THEN it all comes back.

I mean, I remember the major story lines (Cersie getting imprisoned, going to Hardhome, etc.) but certain characters getting killed or other things slip my mind.

6/2/2015 10:15:17 AM

BEU
All American
12512 Posts
user info
edit post

It was 'Dead things in the water'

That also parallels with, the seemingly useless, PatchFace chapters when he goes on these creepy rants about what he saw down at the bottom of the ocean when he was held down for 'days'. Theory goes that the walkers are not just north of the wall but there is something at the bottom of the oceans too. Whether or not they can make it on land is another thing.

In the whole lava/fire/dragons vs cold/walker/whites/DeadThingsInTheWater or whatever, there would be volcanic activity at the bottom of the ocean. So this entire struggle might not be contained to only land.

I still don't know if we will actually be told where this all comes from. I don't see a plot device to get information. Unless Sam finds something in Old-town that tells him what its all about.

6/2/2015 10:54:08 AM

BlackJesus
Suspended
13089 Posts
user info
edit post

^^It's ok, the Game of Thrones books are complete shit

6/2/2015 11:00:56 AM

BlackJesus
Suspended
13089 Posts
user info
edit post

The amount of butthurt coming after Jon Snow's death is going to be epic.

6/3/2015 9:11:03 AM

rjrumfel
All American
23027 Posts
user info
edit post

This was the comment I got after suggesting that Jon was "it" for the next episode:

Quote :
"^^Why does it have to be Jon Snow? That would make no sense as he is the only one who has encountered the series big bad."


Lots of butthurt. Have people not learned that there's no rhyme or reason to the deaths in this show?

6/3/2015 11:14:32 AM

Jeepin4x4
#Pack9
35774 Posts
user info
edit post

don't worry, Olly. Jon always comes back.

6/3/2015 11:39:04 AM

skokiaan
All American
26447 Posts
user info
edit post

Video taped reactions coming

6/3/2015 11:39:37 AM

bbehe
Burn it all down.
18402 Posts
user info
edit post

I really don't think Jon will die in the show.

6/3/2015 11:45:15 AM

jbrick83
All American
23447 Posts
user info
edit post

You mean you don't think he'll die and come back, or just die? Because I don't think anyone thinks he's really going to die because everyone think he'll be one of the last one lefts because of R+L=J.

But they're foreshadowing the fuck out of Olly killing him (if not Olly himself, he'll probably help some Nights Watch dudes kill him). It will just be interesting to see if they just end the season with him being stabbed and laying there like in the books...or if they go ahead and take that next step that Martin hasn't taken yet, and have him warg, be brought back by Melisandre...or just not die all together and just be in really bad shape.

6/3/2015 11:50:48 AM

bbehe
Burn it all down.
18402 Posts
user info
edit post

Melisandre didn't stay behind in the show, so I doubt she returns from Stanis' army to bring him back to life
They've barely touch wargs, minus Bran who hasn't been in this season, so I don't think that's an option


Sure, they foreshadowed a lot with Olly, but I don't see that making a huge difference. I just don't think they'll kill him at all.

6/3/2015 11:58:24 AM

Shrike
All American
9594 Posts
user info
edit post

Granted, while it has yet to happen in the books, Jon didn't just have an epic stare down with the show's biggest baddie to then go the way of Jeor Mormont. GRRM's killings aren't random, and the real main characters of the show/books have been fairly safe from mortal harm. Ned may have been a main character of AGoT, but not ASoIaF. Even if he does get stabbed "to death", they've established more ways to revive people than Marvel at this point.

[Edited on June 3, 2015 at 12:41 PM. Reason : .]

6/3/2015 12:40:09 PM

jbrick83
All American
23447 Posts
user info
edit post

Quote :
"Melisandre didn't stay behind in the show, so I doubt she returns from Stanis' army to bring him back to life
"


I'm thinking she might go back to the Wall in one of the final two episodes. Stannis needs royal blood, and he's not giving up his daughter. I think she might go back to Jon or something along those lines.

6/3/2015 12:54:50 PM

rjrumfel
All American
23027 Posts
user info
edit post

Or is it possible that for this episode 9, rather than kill someone big off, what if they brought someone big back? Like Mance or...Stoneheart?

6/3/2015 1:10:07 PM

BEU
All American
12512 Posts
user info
edit post

They need to end with a WTF moment and begin the next season with one. There are too many right now in the books not to.

John's Death
John's Warg/Resurrection (potentially)
Drogon
Kevin Lanister
Sansa/Reek
Mance
Lady Stoneheart

We still dont know if Stonehearts existence is important, she may never get mentioned in the show. Same thing with Mance.

Lets say they kill Jon for the last episode. I assume hes going to be brought back for reasons mentioned above. If he wargs out, or is simply resurrected, will it happen immediately. If there is a delay in resurrection, does he come back the same? Could he be corrupted? If he gets resurrected by the Nights King, does he come back intelligent due to his blood and be the champion of the Others?

So many possibilities.

6/3/2015 1:35:00 PM

rjrumfel
All American
23027 Posts
user info
edit post

I forgot about Drogon.

They are really forcing Jorah wanting to continue fighting in the pits.

Could be that during his fight, Drogon makes his appearance and burns him to a crisp.

6/3/2015 1:36:23 PM

Money_Jones
Ohhh Farts
12521 Posts
user info
edit post

I'm pretty sure Drogon showing up at the fighting pits was shown in pretty much every trailer for this season, before the season started, so we are definitely going to see that within the next 2 episodes. I didn't think they would be able to get to it, but now I'm thinking we are going to see Jon stabbed as well, and I think that would be a great place to end the season.

6/3/2015 2:03:03 PM

bbehe
Burn it all down.
18402 Posts
user info
edit post

Has GoT ended on a cliffhanger that literally picks up right where it leaves off?

6/3/2015 2:09:13 PM

BlackJesus
Suspended
13089 Posts
user info
edit post

Never going to end in a cliffhanger, this show is too good and doesn't need cheesy cliffhangers to bring the audience back.

Jon Snow is dead this week, there is no way around it.

6/3/2015 2:47:21 PM

Wraith
All American
27257 Posts
user info
edit post

Whatever happens in the show, I guarantee the people who haven't read the books are gonna be pissed. I'm sure there will be a number of "I'm not watching this show anymore" like there was after the Red Wedding.


Also, did Dany mention that Drogon is missing yet in the show? When he shows up in the pits, he had been gone for like a month or two, right?

6/3/2015 2:47:41 PM

BlackJesus
Suspended
13089 Posts
user info
edit post

No they haven't mentioned him being missing, but Tyrion saw him flying free not too long ago.

6/3/2015 3:03:17 PM

rjrumfel
All American
23027 Posts
user info
edit post

They've kinda implied that he's not around several times, because there's only two dragons chained in the crypt.

6/3/2015 3:13:25 PM

bbehe
Burn it all down.
18402 Posts
user info
edit post

Dany has specifically said he wasn't around, that's why she was so surprised when she saw him earlier this season

6/3/2015 3:26:11 PM

jbrick83
All American
23447 Posts
user info
edit post

Quote :
"No they haven't mentioned him being missing, but Tyrion saw him flying free not too long ago.
"


Spouts off about the books...but doesn't even pay attention to the show.

Just saw this somewhere:



[Edited on June 3, 2015 at 3:47 PM. Reason : .]

6/3/2015 3:31:52 PM

BEU
All American
12512 Posts
user info
edit post

^ 3 seconds later,

Enter Drogon,

Torrent of flame and kills everyone in that scene except Dany. Tyrion isnt there so all other characters are sacrifice. Tyrion meets up with her later.

There isnt a way out of whats shown in the picture.

You simplify the story line. You eclipse all other death scenes. And we get John getting stabbed in either same episode or finale.

Hahahah, how the internet would shit itself.

It wont happen unfortunately.

6/3/2015 4:10:22 PM

goalielax
All American
11252 Posts
user info
edit post

They all land...not just Drogon. Because he busted the other two out of dragon jail earlier in the episode in a throwback to Oceans 11 or something. Dany gets on one, while Jorah and Missandei get on the other two. Then they torch the place and take off in formation. Jorah peels off in a missing man formation to save Dany from witnessing him decline due to greyscale.

Dany looks at the camera longingly as he flies away to the east and unknown lands and says "goodbye my love." she turns to Missandei and says

"Jorah was always



Quite the Explorah"

YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

/rollcredits

[Edited on June 3, 2015 at 4:24 PM. Reason : .]

6/3/2015 4:23:41 PM

BlackJesus
Suspended
13089 Posts
user info
edit post

Quote :
"Spouts off about the books...but doesn't even pay attention to the show.

Just saw this somewhere:"


Show me a scene where she says "I lost control of my dragon and its off randomly eating people somewhere.". The non book reading audience has no idea that one of the dragons has been a runaway for the entire season.

And yes the last 2 books in this series are complete garbage. I would say the last two are going to be shit, but I'm not going to read them to find out. When the show ends, I'm done, regardless of how the books turn out.

Quote :
"Dany has specifically said he wasn't around"


He isn't around is not the same as my dragon is rogue and I have no clue where he is.

Honestly if I didn't know the plot this season wouldn't even make logical sense to me.



[Edited on June 3, 2015 at 4:29 PM. Reason : ,]

6/3/2015 4:24:38 PM

goalielax
All American
11252 Posts
user info
edit post

really? the whole scene with the guy bringing in his burned to death kid as dany thinks it's just another eaten goat didn't set that up?

pay attention

6/3/2015 4:27:18 PM

jbrick83
All American
23447 Posts
user info
edit post

^^

^this

6/3/2015 4:27:54 PM

BlackJesus
Suspended
13089 Posts
user info
edit post

^^

1 small scene from the entire season, is going to make everyone know that her dragon is rogue. As I said if you didn't read the book you wouldn't know the damn dragon was off eating people.

And that scene was from the finale LAST YEAR. So you expect average viewers to remember that small scene from a year ago??? gtfo

[Edited on June 3, 2015 at 4:39 PM. Reason : ,]

6/3/2015 4:30:48 PM

goalielax
All American
11252 Posts
user info
edit post

except for the time that it did...in the show...and they had a whole scene about it...

just because you're an idiot and can't remember shit doesn't mean the average viewer is

[Edited on June 3, 2015 at 4:40 PM. Reason : .]

6/3/2015 4:39:21 PM

jbrick83
All American
23447 Posts
user info
edit post

She has the two "tamer" dragons on chains that she can't even control. Drogon has already burned a child alive, she doesn't even know where the fuck he is, and he made a brief appearance this season only to fly away again.

I'm sure show viewers think Dany has him on strict voice command...

6/3/2015 4:41:27 PM

BlackJesus
Suspended
13089 Posts
user info
edit post

Whatever, when people start calling out the plot holes I'll come back and say I told you so. Actually what will happen is they will spend the entire opening showing that the dragon is missing, that it killed a kid, that she chained them up so everyone knows whats coming next.

We shall find out on Sunday whom is right. Title for this week "The Dance of Dragons" so her rogue dragon will come back and eat Jorah. Jon snow should also go ahead and die this week, so they can spend the last episode advancing Arya.



[Edited on June 3, 2015 at 4:56 PM. Reason : ,]

6/3/2015 4:49:03 PM

Jeepin4x4
#Pack9
35774 Posts
user info
edit post

a missing dragon is not a plot hole.

6/3/2015 4:55:29 PM

BlackJesus
Suspended
13089 Posts
user info
edit post

It is when its reappearance is the main event in a episode a year later.

6/3/2015 4:58:35 PM

 Message Boards » Entertainment » Game of Thrones book and show comparisons thread Page 1 ... 11 12 13 14 [15] 16 17 18, Prev Next  
go to top | |
Admin Options : move topic | lock topic

© 2024 by The Wolf Web - All Rights Reserved.
The material located at this site is not endorsed, sponsored or provided by or on behalf of North Carolina State University.
Powered by CrazyWeb v2.39 - our disclaimer.